Medicare Advantage Star Ratings can affect plan funding, benefits, and the conversations agents have with clients.
For 2026, the number of Medicare Advantage contracts earning 4 or more Stars fell from 261 to 207.
That raises an important question:
“Did these plans suddenly get worse?”
In the latest episode of The Insurance Producers Guild, we explain why the answer is more complicated.
Listen here: EP18: Why Medicare Advantage Star Ratings Fell for 2026
Why This Episode Matters
Medicare Advantage Star Ratings are not based on a fixed grading scale.
CMS recalculates rating cut points each year. Measure weights can change, industry performance can improve, and temporary policies can expire.
That means a plan may perform similarly from one year to the next and still receive a lower rating.
For agents, this matters because clients may assume:
- Their plan is no longer good
- Their benefits will disappear
- They need to switch immediately
A lower rating deserves attention.
It does not automatically mean a client should change plans.
What We Cover in This Episode
In EP18, we discuss:
- Why fewer contracts earned 4 or more Stars
- How annual CMS scoring changes affect ratings
- Why the 4-Star threshold matters
- How bonus funding can influence plan benefits
- Recent legal challenges involving Clover Health and Elevance
- What agents should review with clients now
The key message is simple:
The rating may have changed because the scoring system changed—not because the plan suddenly stopped performing.
Why the Four-Star Line Matters
Plans earning at least 4 Stars may qualify for Quality Bonus Program payments.
These dollars can help support benefits such as:
- Dental, vision, and hearing coverage
- Part B givebacks
- Lower premiums
- Reduced cost sharing
- Other supplemental benefits
Total bonus spending increased to approximately $13.4 billion for 2026, but those dollars are now concentrated among fewer contracts.
That does not mean every lower-rated plan will reduce benefits.
It does mean agents should closely review finalized premiums, copays, networks, formularies, and supplemental benefits.
Star Ratings Are Only One Part of the Decision
A Star Rating should never replace a complete needs assessment.
Before recommending a change, agents should compare:
- Doctors and hospitals
- Prescription coverage
- Premiums and copays
- Maximum out-of-pocket costs
- Supplemental benefits
- The client’s health and financial needs
A higher-rated plan is not automatically the best fit.
A lower-rated plan may still serve a client well.
Be the Calm Expert
Clients may hear about lower ratings through ads, carrier notices, or the news.
A clear response might be:
“CMS updates the Star Rating methodology each year. A lower rating does not automatically mean your plan is no longer a good fit. Let’s review your doctors, prescriptions, benefits, and costs before making any decisions.”
The goal is not to defend a carrier.
The goal is to help the client make an informed decision.
Start Client Reviews Early
Do not wait until enrollment season becomes crowded.
Review clients whose contracts experienced a rating change and confirm:
- Providers
- Prescriptions
- Premiums and copays
- Supplemental benefits
- Any health or household changes
Document each review in your CRM and focus on suitability—not switching for the sake of switching.
Where PSM Can Help
PSM Brokerage helps independent agents prepare for Medicare Advantage changes with:
- Competitive plan options
- Enrollment and comparison technology
- Agent training
- CRM solutions
- Marketing resources
- Compliance support
- Dedicated guidance
Because independent should not mean unsupported.
Listen to the Episode
Hear the full conversation here:
Listen to EP18: Why Medicare Advantage Star Ratings Fell for 2026
Final Thought
A lower Star Rating can create concern, but it should not create panic.
Review the complete picture.
Check the benefits. Verify the doctors. Review the prescriptions. Compare the costs.
Then make a recommendation based on what is best for the client.
Ready to Prepare Your Medicare Advantage Book for 2026?
PSM Brokerage gives independent agents access to products, technology, training, marketing support, and experienced guidance.
Connect with PSM Brokerage today.
Topics:
%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-02-05T094830.320.png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-02-05T094830.320.png)
%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-06-02T100845.756.png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-06-02T100845.756.png)
%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-06-02T093238.892.png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-06-02T093238.892.png)
%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-02-27T132155.780.png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-02-27T132155.780.png)
%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-02-25T145928.814.png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-02-25T145928.814.png)
%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-01-29T101508.406.png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20-%202026-01-29T101508.406.png)
%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20(59).png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(1200%20x%20628%20px)%20(59).png)
%20(84)-1.png?width=600&height=338&name=Marketing%20Hub%20CTA%20Image%20(600%20x%20338%20px)%20(84)-1.png)
