CMS CRUSH Rule Targets $90 Billion in Healthcare Fraud
November 18th, 2026
4 min read
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) is taking aim at healthcare fraud with a sweeping new proposal that could reshape oversight across Medicare, Medicaid, and the Affordable Care Act (ACA) Marketplace.
On November 16, 2026, CMS announced the Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare (CRUSH) proposed rule, a major initiative designed to strengthen fraud prevention and potentially save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over the next decade.
For independent insurance agents, the proposal signals a continued shift toward tighter oversight, stronger consumer protections, and greater accountability throughout the healthcare system.
And for agents working in Medicare Advantage or ACA markets, several provisions deserve particular attention.
What Is the CMS CRUSH Rule?
The CRUSH proposal is designed to help CMS identify suspicious activity earlier, prevent improper payments, and remove bad actors from federally funded healthcare programs.
Rather than relying primarily on investigations after fraud occurs, CMS wants stronger tools to identify potential problems before payments are made or consumers are harmed.
The proposal focuses on several areas:
- Stronger provider screening and enrollment verification.
- Expanded Medicare Advantage payment audits.
- More comprehensive fraud reporting requirements.
- Additional protections against unauthorized Marketplace enrollments.
- Greater oversight of agents, brokers, providers, and healthcare organizations.
According to the HHS announcement, the estimated savings would come from multiple program integrity reforms across federal healthcare programs.
Important: CRUSH is currently a proposed rule, not a finalized regulation. The estimated savings are projections, not money already recovered.
Medicare Advantage Faces Stronger Oversight
One of the most significant elements of the proposal involves Medicare Advantage risk adjustment and improper payments.
CMS wants to strengthen its Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) audits, which examine whether diagnoses submitted by Medicare Advantage organizations are supported by appropriate medical records.
If diagnosis information improperly increases a beneficiary's risk score, it can result in higher payments to the plan.
The proposed changes would give CMS additional tools to identify and recover those payments.
The rule would also require Medicare Advantage organizations and Part D sponsors to report suspicious or substantiated fraud, waste, and abuse.
For independent agents, these provisions are primarily directed at carriers and healthcare organizations rather than routine sales activity. However, stronger oversight can influence the broader Medicare Advantage market, including carrier operations and compliance expectations.
Agents should continue monitoring regulatory developments as they prepare for the 2027 plan year.
Related reading: 2027 Medicare Rules: Faster Sales, More Liability
ACA Agents Face New Fraud Prevention Measures
The Marketplace provisions may have more direct implications for insurance agents and brokers.
CMS is proposing expanded authority to investigate and restrict agents, brokers, and web-brokers involved in abusive or unauthorized enrollment activity.
Among the proposed measures are:
- Faster suspensions: CMS could immediately suspend Marketplace agreements based on credible allegations of abusive conduct likely to harm consumers or the Exchange.
- Stronger termination authority: CMS could terminate agreements when abusive conduct is established under the proposed evidentiary standard.
- A 30-day response window: Agents who fail to refute identified noncompliance within 30 calendar days could face agreement termination and other penalties.
- Additional system security: Agents and brokers would need reasonable safeguards against Marketplace system access originating outside the United States, including through VPN connections routed abroad.
- Expanded eligibility restrictions: Certain criminal convictions or exclusions from federally funded healthcare programs could prevent Marketplace participation.
These measures are intended to address unauthorized enrollments, fraudulent coverage changes, and misuse of consumer information.
For legitimate ACA agents, the message is straightforward: documentation, consumer authorization, and secure enrollment practices will remain critical.
For more on the broader federal enforcement environment, see Medicaid Program Integrity Is Getting More Federal Attention.
New Protections Against Unsolicited Medicare Marketing
The CRUSH proposal also addresses unwanted marketing activity involving durable medical equipment, prosthetics, orthotics, and supplies (DMEPOS).
CMS wants to expand existing restrictions on unsolicited telephone contact to include certain text messages, social media messages, emails, and door-to-door solicitation.
These provisions are specifically directed at medical equipment suppliers and their agents. They should not be confused with the separate Medicare Advantage and Part D marketing requirements that apply to insurance agents.
Still, the proposal reinforces CMS's broader emphasis on consumer consent and protection against misleading outreach.
Insurance agents should continue following applicable CMS marketing regulations, carrier guidelines, and permission-to-contact requirements.
Related reading: Website Compliance Rules Every Medicare Agent Should Know
What Should Independent Insurance Agents Do Now?
Although CRUSH has not been finalized, there are practical steps agents can take to prepare for increased regulatory scrutiny.
1. Strengthen enrollment documentation. Maintain clear records of consumer authorization, enrollment activity, and required disclosures. For ACA business, ensure clients have expressly authorized enrollment or coverage changes.
2. Review access to Marketplace systems. Agents using remote teams, virtual assistants, or VPN connections should review how enrollment platforms are accessed. The proposed geographic access restrictions make system security particularly important.
3. Monitor carrier compliance communications. Medicare Advantage and Part D organizations could face expanded reporting obligations. Agents should watch for any resulting changes to carrier procedures or training.
4. Keep marketing practices compliant. Review outreach methods, consent records, and advertising materials to ensure they meet current requirements.
5. Stay informed as the rule develops. Proposed language can change before a final rule is issued. Agents should avoid treating CRUSH provisions as already effective.
PSM offers additional education and business development resources through the PSM Agent Academy.
When Would the CRUSH Rule Take Effect?
CMS released the proposal on November 16, 2026, and is accepting public comments through January 19, 2027.
The proposal is not a blanket set of new agent requirements taking effect on January 1, 2027. Implementation dates would depend on the final rule and its individual provisions.
CMS estimates that the quantified provisions could generate nearly $90 billion in federal budget savings between 2027 and 2036, with approximately $378.5 million in associated costs. Those estimates remain subject to public comment and potential changes.
CMS+1
Agents and agencies interested in reviewing the proposal can access the official CMS fact sheet or the full proposed rule.
The Bottom Line for Insurance Agents
The CRUSH proposal is another indication that CMS is placing greater emphasis on fraud prevention, enrollment integrity, and accountability across federal healthcare programs.
For Medicare agents, the immediate focus is stronger oversight of health plans, providers, and improper payments.
For ACA agents, the proposal goes further by introducing potential new enforcement authorities and security requirements directly affecting Marketplace participation.
The takeaway: Compliance is becoming an increasingly important part of operating a successful insurance business. Agents who maintain accurate records, protect consumer information, and stay current with regulatory changes will be better positioned to navigate what comes next.
At PSM Brokerage, we help independent insurance agents stay informed with industry updates, training resources, and dedicated support.
Explore our insurance agent training resources to keep building your knowledge and your business.
Editorial note: This article describes a proposed federal regulation as of November 18, 2026. It is intended for insurance industry education and does not constitute legal or regulatory advice.
As CEO & Partner of PSM Brokerage, Lucas helps guide the company’s strategy for supporting independent insurance professionals with training, marketing, technology, carrier access, and business development resources.
Topics: