Medicare, ACA, and Life Insurance News

Medigap Enrollment Surges 7.4% as Medicare Advantage Growth Slows

Written by Lucas Vandenberg | Thu, Nov 19, 2026 @ 10:25 PM

New enrollment data points to changing Medicare preferences—and a growing opportunity for independent insurance agents.

The Medicare market may be entering a new chapter.

For years, Medicare Advantage has driven much of the industry's enrollment growth. But new data suggests Medicare Supplement insurance, commonly known as Medigap, is gaining momentum as more beneficiaries evaluate their coverage options.

According to an October 30, 2026, report from Weiss Ratings, Medigap enrollment increased 7.4% over the 12 months ending in Q2 2026, compared with just 1.7% growth for Medicare Advantage.

For independent insurance agents, the numbers highlight an important trend: Medicare beneficiaries may be placing greater value on provider flexibility, predictable out-of-pocket costs, and long-term coverage stability.

Weiss Ratings

The Numbers Behind the Medigap Growth

Weiss Ratings analyzed insurer statutory filings from Q2 2024 through Q2 2026, revealing a notable shift in enrollment momentum.

MEDIGAP ENROLLMENT GROWTH
+7.4%
Q2 2025–Q2 2026

MEDICARE ADVANTAGE GROWTH
+1.7%
Q2 2025–Q2 2026

MedigapMedicare Advantage0%2%4%6%8%2024–20252025–2026

The report also identified several developments:

  • Medigap enrollment increased from approximately 6.20 million to 6.65 million in the insurer filings analyzed.
  • Medicare Advantage enrollment increased from approximately 28.34 million to 28.82 million.
  • Medigap accounted for nearly half of the combined net enrollment gains across the two product categories during the latest 12-month period.
  • The number of reporting insurers declined in both markets.

These figures reflect the reporting population and methodology used by Weiss Ratings, rather than a comprehensive count of every Medicare beneficiary with supplemental coverage.

Weiss Ratings

Why More Beneficiaries May Be Considering Medicare Supplement

Medicare Advantage remains an important coverage option for millions of Americans. However, several factors may be encouraging beneficiaries to take a closer look at Original Medicare paired with a Medicare Supplement policy.

Provider flexibility. Medigap works alongside Original Medicare, generally allowing beneficiaries to see any healthcare provider nationwide who accepts Medicare. That flexibility may appeal to individuals who travel frequently or want greater freedom when choosing specialists.

Fewer network concerns. Medicare Advantage plans commonly use provider networks and may require prior authorization for certain services. For beneficiaries concerned about changing networks or access to care, Original Medicare with Medigap offers a different coverage structure.

Greater predictability. Depending on the standardized plan selected, Medigap can help reduce exposure to certain Medicare deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance.

That predictability comes with a tradeoff: Medigap policies generally carry additional monthly premiums, which can increase over time. Beneficiaries also typically need separate Part D coverage for outpatient prescription drugs.

The growing interest in Medigap does not mean Medicare Advantage is disappearing. It means agents need to be prepared to explain both coverage paths clearly.

What This Means for Independent Insurance Agents

The changing enrollment picture creates an opportunity for agents who offer a diversified Medicare portfolio.

1. Make Medicare Supplement Part of Every Appropriate Coverage Discussion

Agents who primarily focus on Medicare Advantage may be overlooking beneficiaries who prioritize provider access and cost predictability.

Presenting both Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare with Medigap allows clients to make more informed decisions based on their healthcare needs, finances, and preferences.

2. Understand Medigap Enrollment Rights

One of the most important considerations is timing.

Unlike Medicare Advantage, Medigap generally does not offer an annual guaranteed enrollment opportunity.

Under federal rules, most beneficiaries age 65 or older receive a six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period beginning when they first enroll in Medicare Part B. Outside that window, medical underwriting may apply unless an individual qualifies for guaranteed-issue protections or additional state-specific rights.

A 2026 KFF analysis of Medigap enrollment protections outlines how these rules vary across states.

Agents should verify eligibility and underwriting requirements before recommending a transition from Medicare Advantage to Medigap.

3. Build a Stronger Medicare Supplement Carrier Portfolio

Medicare Supplement plans with the same standardized letter generally offer the same core benefits, regardless of the insurance company offering them.

However, premiums, pricing methods, underwriting requirements, available discounts, and carrier financial strength can vary.

A diversified carrier portfolio helps agents compare available options and respond to changing client needs.

Explore PSM Brokerage's Medicare Solutions to learn more about Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage, and Part D opportunities.

4. Focus on Education, Not Just Enrollment

Many beneficiaries do not fully understand the differences between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement.

This creates an opportunity for agents to build trust through educational conversations, coverage comparisons, and ongoing client service.

The goal is not to steer every client toward Medigap. It is to help clients understand their options and select coverage that fits their circumstances.

Agents looking to strengthen their product knowledge can also explore the PSM Agent Academy for Medicare education, sales strategies, and business development training.

The Bigger Picture: Medicare Is Becoming a More Diverse Market

Medigap's growth deserves attention, but it is only one part of a changing Medicare landscape.

Medicare Advantage remains a major market, particularly for beneficiaries interested in integrated benefits and lower monthly premiums. At the same time, Medicare Supplement may attract more attention from individuals seeking flexibility and a different approach to managing healthcare expenses.

For agents, the opportunity is not about choosing one product category over another.

It is about having the knowledge, carrier access, and resources to serve clients regardless of which Medicare path they choose.

As enrollment preferences evolve, independent agents who can effectively explain both options will be well-positioned to build stronger client relationships and expand their businesses.

Position Your Business for the Next Medicare Opportunity

At PSM Brokerage, we help independent insurance agents build competitive Medicare portfolios with carrier access, dedicated account management, training, technology, and business development support.

Whether you focus on Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage, or both, having the right resources can help you adapt to the changing marketplace.

Explore our Medicare Solutions and prepare your business for what's next.

For insurance agent use only. Not affiliated with the U.S. government or federal Medicare program. Enrollment figures are based on Weiss Ratings' analysis of insurer statutory filings and may differ from other industry datasets.